Star reviews, star sales: how to get reviews for your online store

Star reviews, star sales: how to get reviews for your online store

Peter Gáborík
Published
Updated
7 min read
ReviewsE-commerceTrustpilot
Share this article:Add on Google

Online store reviews replace personal experience for a new customer: they decide whether to trust you with their money. Collect them mainly through your Google Business Profile, Google store ratings, an independent platform such as Trustpilot and your own product reviews. What matters is volume, freshness, how you respond to criticism and, in the EU, the legal duty to say how you verify reviews.

In brief:

  • According to the Spiegel Research Center, a product with five reviews is 270% more likely to be purchased than a product with none.
  • Customers look for fresh ratings: 74% focus on reviews from the last three months (BrightLocal 2026).
  • The EU Omnibus Directive requires you to state whether and how you check that reviews come from real customers. Fake reviews are banned.
  • Google prohibits incentives for reviews and selectively asking only happy customers.
  • The most reliable source of reviews is an automated email a few days after delivery.

Why online store reviews drive sales

Online, there is no personal contact with the product or the seller. Store ratings answer the questions a product description cannot: will the order arrive, does it match the photos and how does the store handle problems.

The Spiegel Research Center found that a product with five reviews is 270% more likely to be purchased than one without. For higher-priced products the conversion rate rose by 380%, for lower-priced ones by 190%. The benefit of additional reviews drops quickly after the first five, so you gain the most by getting products with no ratings to their first five.

Purchase likelihood tends to peak at an average of 4.0–4.7, not at a perfect five stars – a flawless score looks suspicious. A few critical reviews with a factual reply from the store will not hurt trust.

Reviews therefore raise your conversion rate without extra ad spend.

What customers expect from reviews

The BrightLocal 2026 survey (US consumers of local businesses) shows trends that apply to online stores too:

  • Freshness: 74% of people focus on reviews from the last three months, 32% on the last two weeks.
  • A higher bar: 68% of customers require at least four stars, 31% even 4.5 or more.
  • Responses: 89% expect the owner to respond to reviews, 81% within a week.

Reviews are not a one-off campaign. You need a system that collects them continuously and someone who responds.

Where to collect reviews

PlatformWhere it showsBest forNote
Google Business ProfileGoogle Search and Mapsstores with a pickup point, showroom or strong brandreviews visible when people search your store name
Google store ratingsGoogle ads and free listingsstores using Google Merchant Centerusually requires at least 100 verified reviews
TrustpilotTrustpilot profile, widget on your sitestores selling across marketsindependent platform, free plan available
Your own product reviewsproduct pagesevery online storecan appear as stars in search results

Independent review platforms

A platform such as Trustpilot gives customers a place to rate you outside your own site, which makes the ratings more credible to new visitors. Some markets have strong local players: in the Czech Republic and Slovakia, for example, the price comparison site Heureka collects verified store and product reviews through a post-purchase questionnaire linked to the store’s product feed. Check which platform your customers actually use before paying for one.

For product-level reviews, the key is matching each order to the product IDs in your product feed, so the platform knows what the customer bought and can ask about the right items. How product feeds work is covered in our guide to the XML product feed.

Google reviews

Reviews on your Google Business Profile appear when a customer searches for your store name. Store ratings in ads and product listings (via Google Merchant Center) usually appear only once you have 100 verified reviews, and in ads only with an average of at least 3.5 stars.

Reviews on product pages

Ratings on product pages help most, because they sit where the customer hesitates. If you mark them up with structured data (the `Product` type with a rating), Google may show stars in search results. Note: ratings a business publishes about itself, for example on a page marked up as `Organization` or `LocalBusiness`, will not be shown as stars.

The rules: EU consumer law and Google

Since 28 May 2022, the Omnibus Directive (EU) 2019/2161 has applied across the EU, amending the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. For reviews it creates two obligations:

  1. 1Disclose your verification. If you give customers access to product reviews, you must state whether and how you ensure they come from people who actually bought or used the product (Article 7(6)). A short line next to the reviews is enough, for example “Only customers with a verified order can leave a review.” If you do not verify reviews, you must say so too.
  2. 2No fake or manipulated reviews. Writing invented reviews, commissioning them from others, deleting or editing ratings and misleading claims about verification are banned practices (Annex I, points 23b and 23c), enforced by national consumer authorities.

Google’s rules are even stricter. For reviews in Maps and Search it prohibits incentives for reviews (money, discounts or gifts), asking only happy customers, reviews from employees or the owner and paid reviews in any form.

For stars in search results, Google’s current guidelines (2026) explicitly state that a page must not contain fake reviews or incentivized reviews without clear disclosure. Violations can lead to a manual action and loss of the stars. A safe rule: ask all customers equally and do not reward ratings.

How to collect reviews after purchase: step by step

Happy customers rarely write a review because nobody asks them at the right moment. An automated email for every order works best:

  1. 1Pick the right time. Send the request 3–7 days after delivery, not after dispatch. The trigger is the “delivered” status.
  2. 2Choose one goal. One email, one call to action – Google, an independent platform or a product rating.
  3. 3Keep it short. A thank-you, a direct link to the rating form and a note that it takes a minute.
  4. 4Add one reminder. If the customer does not respond, one gentle reminder after 5–7 days is enough.
  5. 5Respond to reviews. Thank people for positive ones, reply to negative ones within 48 hours with an offer to fix the issue.
  6. 6Measure. Track the share of orders that end with a review and the average rating month by month. If it drops, test the send time and subject line.

You can set up the request in your email tool or directly in your store platform. We explain how to build automated campaigns in our email marketing guide. If the email also contains an offer or discount, it counts as marketing and must follow those rules, including an unsubscribe option.

How to respond to a negative review

Every future visitor reads a critical review, so your reply is a public business card. A proven structure has four steps: thanks, acknowledging the problem without excuses (“The late delivery was our mistake.”), a concrete fix (“A replacement shipped today.”) and a contact for next steps.

Do not argue and do not reveal the customer’s personal data. Report reviews that break the rules (profanity, clearly fake content) to the platform – you cannot delete them yourself on Google or Trustpilot.

When to bring in experts

Turning on review requests and sending the first ones is something you can do yourself. Bring in experts when your store, product feed, review platform and email automation need to work together so requests go out at the right time and stars show up in search. If you are still planning your store, start with how to start an online store. At Weboptim we have 9+ years and more than 50 projects behind us. See how our ecommerce website development works, or get in touch and we will suggest how to build review collection into your store.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get reviews for my online store?
The most reliable way is an automated email asking for a rating 3 to 7 days after the order is delivered, with a direct link to the form. Combine your Google Business Profile with Google store ratings and, if your customers use it, an independent platform such as Trustpilot. Ask all customers equally, add at most one reminder and respond to every review.
Do I need Trustpilot, or are Google reviews enough?
For many smaller stores, Google reviews and ratings on product pages are enough, because that is where customers see them while deciding. An independent platform makes sense when you sell across several markets or want ratings that visitors see as independent of your own site. Check first which platform your customers actually use.
Can I give customers a discount for writing a review?
Not for Google reviews. Google’s rules prohibit offering money, discounts or gifts for reviews and also prohibit asking only happy customers. If you offered a reward for reviews on your own site, it would have to be clearly disclosed, otherwise you risk losing stars in search and breaching EU consumer law. The safest option is not to reward ratings.
Does an online store have to say how it verifies reviews?
In the EU, yes. Under the Omnibus Directive, a trader that displays product reviews must state whether and how it ensures they come from customers who bought or used the product. A short note next to the reviews or in your terms is enough. If you do not verify reviews, you must say so explicitly.
How does a product feed help with reviews?
A product feed lists your products for shopping platforms, but it also helps with reviews. When your review tool sends the IDs of purchased products and they match the IDs in your feed, the platform can collect product-level reviews and ask about the right items. Without it, you usually get only a general store rating.
Can I delete a negative review?
Not yourself. On Google and independent platforms you can only report a review if it breaks the platform’s rules, for example contains profanity, is clearly fake or comes from a competitor. A review that is unpleasant but true must not be deleted or edited, that is an unfair commercial practice. The best response is a quick, factual public reply offering a fix.
Peter Gáborík

Written by

Peter Gáborík

Project Manager – AI, Automation & SEO

Project manager and founder of Weboptim. Builds growth strategies around SEO, automation and AI; in online marketing since 2017.

Related service

E-Commerce

View service

Tips that save time – once a month

One e-mail a month: a new guide, the automation of the month and one number from practice. No spam.